Understanding Women:
A Man’s Guide to
Relationship Rocket Science
Clay Watkins, LMFT
Robert Evans, producer of The Godfather
The following article is a work-in-progress meant to
stimulate discussion between men and women. As such it is somewhat
tongue-in-cheek, but there is much truth in it as well. Readers are encouraged
to provide feedback to assist in increasing the accuracy of the descriptions of
how women think, feel and behave. If your input is used in the author’s
upcoming book, you may be cited as a contributor. Obviously any generalizations
made are by definition not going to apply to some women, therefore please
forgive the author if they do not apply to you. As country singer Tammy Wynette
says in the song Stand By Your Man,
“...after all he’s just a man.”
Women:
The Ultimate Puzzle for Men
To us men, women are simultaneously
frustrating and wonderful. We peer at a woman as a chimpanzee might peer at a
computer; mesmerized by the pretty lights; simultaneously fearful and awed by
the mystery of it all. But take heart, men. There is a method to women’s
madness. To truly understand these amazing creatures, however, we must be
willing to expand our perspective. We must be willing to defy principles of
standard male logic. We must do that which does not come naturally. We must
think like women.
First,
forget all you heard about women as a
kid. What we men pick up in childhood about the female mind—the guesses you
got from your elementary school buddies—is useless drivel. This
includes statements like “When a girl says ‘No’ she really means ‘Yes’”; crap
like that.
Second,
forget what you’ve been told about women
by women. We men all know women don’t even understand themselves. How in
heaven’s name are they going to explain it to us? They illustrate this with
cryptic phrases like “I really like it when a man cries,” “I’d rather just
cuddle,” and “If you don’t know by now, then I’m not going to tell you.”
The key is observation. Women are too complex to be fully
understood by any one man. That’s a given. The best any of us can hope for is
partial but significant understanding. Think of it as you might rocket science;
with enough education, experience and elbow grease you can put together
something that will get you into space. Then you press the ignition switch and
pray things go well. The key is watching and listening. We’re not talking about
stalking women, hacking into their email, or reading their text messages. We’re
talking about watching what they do and correctly interpreting what they say.
The
U.S. Marines have a motto: Improvise.
Adapt. Overcome. It’s not important that you win every battle. The priority
in this case is to win the war; the war against your own selfishness; the war
against petty arguments; the war against broken relationships. If your goal is
to make your relationship work no matter what, then you’ll need more than just
commitment. You’ll need some creativity as well.
Who
do you think you are, anyway?
I realize the first question many
readers will ask is: how in heaven’s name does this male author have the cajones to claim to understand women? I
might even entertain the bigger question of how any man can presume to understand the opposite sex. I admit I am
making a bold statement, but I do so not because of my education or my
intellect or my professional training. More than any other reason, I understand women because I listen to them; hundreds of them. As a marriage and
family therapist I see wives, girlfriends and moms every day and they tell me
their deepest longings; their joys; their disappointments; their fears; even
their fantasies. And you can bet I take copious notes to ensure I don’t forget
what they tell me. I even bounce the concepts off other women
to make sure I understand what I’m hearing. And the
conclusions I have made may surprise you.
For
All You Outliers
Let me extend a sincere apology to
those hopefully very few men who read this article, but for whom it is of no
assistance. Writing an article on understanding women from a man’s perspective
is a grand undertaking, and one that is inherently incomplete. I might as well
be writing a primer on how to cut diamonds. Just as every raw diamond has its
individual traits, molecular makeup and structural idiosyncrasies; no one woman
is the same as the next. The best any man can do is gather data and from them
make his best guess.
To
truly understand any particular woman, a man must understand the general
principles of how women think, feel and act, but then also learn to adapt this
understanding to the one woman he wishes to love. The bad news is, due to the
complexity of the task, your challenges will be many; your failures will be
frequent; and your mistakes will be
painful. The good news: if you can think outside your own experience,
develop the complex man inside you, and learn to communicate the right message
clearly over and over, you may just experience a truly loving relationship.
Marriage
Is Not For Sissies
As I write this I am reminded of a joke about a man who,
while walking along the beach finds an ornate bottle. Upon removing the top a
genie appears and says, “I am so grateful to you for setting me free, I will
gladly grant you any one wish.” The man asks, “One? I thought it was always
three wishes?” To which the genie replies, “I’m an apprentice. I can only grant
one.” The man thinks for a moment and says, “My wife always wanted us to go to
Hawaii, but she has a severe phobia of flying. Can you make me a highway to
Hawaii so I can drive her there?” The genie grimaces and complains, “Wow,
that’s a really big request. Do you know how many cubic yards of concrete that
would take, and the engineering that would go into a bridge that long? Can’t
you think of anything else you want that might be a little easier?” The man
thinks for a long
minute and says, “Okay, my wife is always saying I don’t
understand her. Can you just teach me how to understand women?” To this the
genie replies, “Did you want two or four lanes on that highway?”
Coming
to a working understanding of women, at least from a man’s perspective,
requires nothing short of rocket science. But it is possible, given a certain
combination of courage, persistence and humility. You are probably reading this
article to help you repair a problem in your relationship with a woman. Some
advice: there are no quick fixes with
women. Every problem with a woman takes time, effort and consistency to
rectify. It’s part of the price we men pay to get all the great things women
have to offer. No use complaining because you were unaware of the fine print.
Time to man-up. Along those same lines, this article isn’t for incrementalists.
If you think you’re going to get a better relationship by slightly modifying
your present relationship, good luck with that. This article isn’t for you. To
achieve a very different relationship you’ll have to do something very
different than what you’ve done in the past.
With
regard to relationships with women, we
men often feel we are set up to fail. To say women are complex is a massive
understatement. We men are psychological square pegs attempting to fit into
round holes. The only way to truly fit is to allow our angles to be rounded
off. It’s not a matter of becoming who we’re not--it’s a matter of becoming who
we can be, so we can experience and give the very best. You can spend your time
attempting to square-up the round hole, but in my experience, it’s more
productive to work on changing yourself.
The
Devil Is in the Differences
Herein lies the problem; if men and
women think and react in an inherently different manner, how can the sexes ever
hope to get along? Mutual understanding is the answer. Let’s start with
understanding the physiological differences.
There
are, of course, the obvious disparities between the sexes involving genitalia, hormones, chromosomes, and
appreciation for the Three Stooges. But what’s really interesting is how our
brains function differently. Brain size and intelligence between men and women
is generally the same, but important structural differences exist between the
sexes that create differing responses to events around us.
It starts before we are ever born. Sometime
between three and six months into pregnancy, hormones wash over a pre-born
child’s cranial cavity to catalyze brain growth. Specifically the brain of
fetal boys is bombarded with testosterone; shrinking the corpus collosum; a structure that allows us to communicate between
the left and right hemispheres of the brain. This at least partially explains
why in functional brain scans adult women appear more adept at using both
hemispheres of the brain, whereas men tend to spend most of their brain activity
in the left hemisphere only. So men, when your wife accuses you of being
brain-damaged, just say, “That’s technically true, but what’s your point?”
The
left side of the brain—where men spend most of their time—is where logic and
rationality typically occur. By contrast, women
use both sides of their brain; accessing not only left brain functions, but
also right brain functions like intuition and emotions. By deduction one might
conclude men are more logical than women, or conversely that women are inherently
smarter than men since they use both sides of their brain. Both arguments miss
the point. What’s important is not that women process information differently
than do men, which they do; most important is that this causes women to feel differently than men, which is why, even
when given the same set of facts, women and men often arrive at very different
conclusions.
The
fact that women take their feelings into consideration when making decisions
may work fine for them, but from a man’s standpoint this is inefficient. From a
male perspective, emotions merely complicate the thinking process. Not only
that, we men fear emotions will make us look like sissies, so we take great
pains to manage them effectively. In fact, if we men could get by without any emotion
we would. But men, to successfully communicate and negotiate with women, we must learn to understand how women
translate their feelings and their experiences. This may seem impossible,
but it’s not. It just takes some work.
Throughout
their school ages, boys have testosterone pulsing through their bodies;
propelling them into more frequent fights and more behavioral problems than
generally are experienced by little girls. As a result, much of little boys’ emotional experience and expression is shaped by
schoolyard politics. Boys learn early that most all emotional expression
other than happiness or anger is unacceptable on the playground. If a little
boy strikes out in softball then cries about it, he is quickly ostracized by
his peers and often ridiculed as well. But if the same boy curses and
throws his bat to the ground in anger,
though he may pay some price if a teacher notices, he gains respect or fear
from his peers. So then later, when the boy becomes a man, and his wife asks
him to show vulnerability, disappointment or compassion, one should not be
surprised when he reacts like a deer in the headlights. He frankly has no idea
how to feel anything but happiness or anger.
Similarly,
on the playground boys learn to limit their words more than girls do, because
boys know that past a certain point their words become fightin’ words, leading to violent repercussions. Contrary to
popular belief, most little boys would rather avoid fisticuffs, so statements
like “Oh yeah? Well make me!” are more often followed up with deflections like
“Every time I spit I make you!” than by fighting words like, “Oh yeah? Then
behind the green backstop after school, you pussy!”
By
contrast, little girls learn to use
their words in what boys consider overly harsh ways, because girls are just
not as prone toward solving their conflicts through physical violence. And
because they don’t have to fear that a physical fight will break out if they
say something nasty, this sets up a verbal free-for-all when girls argue. As a
result, little girls can get really good at hurting with their words.
Unfortunately by the time girls grow up to be women, they have also gained a
vast verbal advantage over men in arguments.
To
compound this inequity between the sexes, consider also that even when little
boys do get into fights, they rarely hit below the belt. Why? Because every
little boy knows how much it hurts to get hit in the groin—that’s why. And
every little boy also knows guys’ rule number thirteen: if you live by the sword, you will die by the sword. This goes for
words as well. Little boys don’t make fun of other little boys’ penises,
because if they did they know they would be just one conversation away from
being the brunt of the next small-penis-joke. Little girls, conversely, have no
such understanding. Guys must understand this and learn to disregard women when
they go too far. They just don’t know any better. No one ever taught them guys’ rules.
This
brings us to a very dicey topic for men: how
to know when to act on what a woman says and when not to. Aha! Finally
something that makes sense. All men recognize the double bind of listening to a
woman’s words. We hear things from her like, “I want you to be sensitive to my
needs, but don’t be a doormat,” or “Why can’t you spend more time with me; but
could you work more overtime to help our finances?” Deep down women want a guy
who has goals and ideas; who’s a leader and
not a follower; who cares and
sacrifices for his wife but won’t sacrifice his dignity. But ask a woman how to
achieve both sides of what they say they want and they’ll give you nothing but
gibberish. My wife, as I was writing this, said, “Don’t forget to mention that
women have the ability to feel opposite emotions at the same time. We can hate
and love someone simultaneously.” I just looked at her with that thousand-yard
stare I sometimes get in our conversations. What are we men supposed to do with
this nonsense? Improvise. Adapt. Overcome. Your best bet? Just do the right
thing for the right reasons, and let the chips fall where they may. It’s not a
perfect solution, but at least you’ll be able to sleep at night. Unless she’s
PMSing, in which case, watch your back!
It
is, however, altogether necessary for us men to learn how to feel emotions,
other than the two previously-mentioned ones, as well as express them to our
significant others. For a good start into being able to do that, read the book The 7 Levels of Verbal Intimacy by
Matthew Kelly.
Men are visual. For men, visual stimulation-- whether
it’s actual girl-watching or looking through a Playboy magazine—equates to
brain stimulation. In 1956, James Olds performed a famous experiment whereby
rats were taught to press a bar wired to a miniature electrode that delivered
electrical stimulation to the hypothalamus of the rat’s brain; the “pleasure
center” if you will. The rats were deprived of food and then given the choice
between eating and self-stimulation. The rats always chose the pleasure stimulation. As many as 5,000 stimuli
were self-delivered to the rats’ hypothalamic region. The animals stopped only
when they dropped from exhaustion. Similar to rats, we men will choose that
which stimulates the pleasure center of the brain, even sometimes to our own
detriment. Unfortunately women, evolved creatures that they are, are often able
to see past the exterior to who a man is on the inside. The problem is, they
expect us to be able to do the same, so we disappoint them a lot.
Do yourself a favor: love
your wife. A lot of
guys see these differences and try to solve the conflict by educating their wives or girlfriends. I
see many of these men in my office, after years of trying but inevitably
failing to convince their women that their wandering eye or online porn
addiction is somehow “normal”. Pick your battles, men. If you’re in a committed
relationship, you have to give up on all those parts of your life that
undermine your lady’s self-esteem. It may be difficult, but you must exercise
self-discipline. Don’t disrespect your woman by looking another woman up and
down in
front of her and making comments like,
“Wow, will you look at the pair on that one!” Instead, take the opportunity to
throw her a compliment. Building her self-esteem will reap many rewards for you
later.
Men
translate what a woman says into a statement about respect, whereas women translate everything a man says into
a statement about relationship. Little known secret; when a man says something—anything—to
his wife, deep down she is asking one question: “Are you on my side?” Smart men
find a way to imbed, even multiple times per day, the following message in
their communications with their wives: “I love you, I am committed to you, and
I’m willing to sacrifice my comfort for your happiness.” The cause of most
divorces is not money or cheating; it is the lack of including this simple
imbedded message in all our interactions. From a guy’s standpoint this is
ridiculous. As I heard one husband tell his wife, “I told you I loved you the
day we got married, and I’ll let you know if I ever change my mind.” Heed my
words, men. This does not work for women. They need to be regularly reminded
that they are loved. Don’t struggle against it. You don’t need to know why it
is. It just is.
The point system. Because women use more of their right
brain (where emotion and relationship information are processed) than men do,
they prioritize events, words and choices differently than men do. So when a
guy brings home a dozen roses, he may think he gets 12 emotional points in his
favor, but in reality he may only earn one point according to his wife. In fact
he could have brought home just one single rose and still earned one point. (I
know, it makes no sense!) The fact is, women assign relational points according
to many factors: thoughtfulness, sincerity, sacrifice, history, timing,
spontaneity. Cost is a tricky factor that can go either way. One thing is for
sure; each woman’s point system is unique, so best do some research to get it
right. Gary Chapman’s book The Five Love
Languages is an excellent guide to determining how to score emotional
points with your mate. Read it. Live it. Be it.
Communicating With Women
In the book How
To Talk So Kids Will Listen & Listen So Kids Will Talk, Adele
Faber and Elaine Mazlish suggest a four-part strategy on how to effectively
communicate with kids, but it also works quite well between a man and a woman:
1.
Listen actively to the point she’s making.
Say your girlfriend says, “You never let me have a say in things. Quit
controlling me!” Before you defend yourself or respond to what you perceive as
disrespect, construct a statement to let her know you are listening to her. For
example: “Wow, it sounds like you’re pretty upset. This must be really
important to you.”
2.
Acknowledge her point by mirroring it, using a combination of your and her words. Let her
know you understand what she’s saying by feeding back what you think you heard.
For example: “So if I have this right, you’re mad because it seems like I don’t
ask your opinion before I make decisions, right?” Make your best guess, but be
open to correction if you got it wrong.
3.
Empathize with her by labeling and reflecting
her emotion. Construct a statement that helps her recognize and relate to her
own emotions. For example: “I think I get it; that you feel powerless—like
you’re not being respected. I can see why you’d be pretty upset about that.”
4.
Respond by reframing her situation, exploring
options and solutions with her. Construct a statement that leads her toward a
solution that works for everyone. For example: “Okay, so what do you think I
can do to make sure you get more of what you want; so it seems more fair to
you?”
We
men see ourselves as problem solvers. Our tendency is to jump straight to step
4 to explore solutions. This way, we reason, the messiness of steps 2 and 3 is
eliminated altogether, allowing us to feel both efficient and useful. When we
make this jump, however, it makes a woman feel devalued because she thinks we
only see her as a project and not as a person. I know it sounds crazy, but it’s
how women think. Don’t struggle against it. It will only close more tightly
around you. Instead, improvise; adapt; overcome.
Guys,
do yourselves a favor and focus on steps 2 and 3. Trust me. She will not only
feel loved, but often she’ll forget the need to solve the problem that started
the discussion in the first place! Important point here guys: for women the issue is always about the
relationship. So-called “problems” are only important to them insofar as
they impact the relationship.
Conclusions
This article is merely a look at the tip of the iceberg of
challenges associated with understanding women. For most men, understanding
their wives will be a lifelong effort. My main point: it is a worthwhile
effort, and though you’ll never completely understand her, with some smarts,
some patience, and some commitment, you can understand her well enough to make
her feel loved. And that, in turn, will change how she treats you, which can
make life very worth living.